Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Chris Siebrasse's avatar

Never since 250 years ago have we been so desperate for a free press. The issues that fueled the drive for independence are now current events.

Expand full comment
Ralph Rosenberg's avatar

Dave, I want to first commend you for the thoughtful work you're doing on your Substack. What stands out most is how you actually engage with your commentators and readers—a rarity in the Substack universe where too many writers treat their newsletters as one-way megaphones. Your willingness to respond, discuss, and genuinely listen creates the kind of community dialogue that journalism desperately needs right now.

Your piece on journalism education adapting to the current crisis is timely and important. But I'd argue there's a deeper failure we need to confront: over the past 10+ years, journalism schools appear to have failed to train journalists to effectively address lies and misinformation and successfully confront and overcome claims of fake news. This failure has become exponentially more dangerous with the rise of AI-generated content and viral memes—both of which can weaponize falsehoods at unprecedented scale and speed. I am speaking in terms of generalities, of course. For example, Missouri and Iowa State Daily recent editors deserve praise, and of course many on substack.

Margaret Sullivan recently wrote about how the "partisan bickering" frame fails the public—presenting false equivalences when one side is simply lying while the other is stating facts. This bothsidesism has become journalism's original sin, and it may start in J-schools where aspiring journalists learn to prize "balance" over truth-telling. Perhaps Missouri and ISU are different. Other examples of media criticism includes currying favor with a current administration and corporate media philosophies: https://www.stopthepresses.news/p/the-medias-kissing-up-to-trump-started?r=9e9e3&utm_campaign=post&utm_medium=web&showWelcomeOnShare=false or https://open.substack.com/pub/saltypolitics/p/the-day-corporate-media-finally-died?r=9e9e3&utm_campaign=post&utm_medium=web&showWelcomeOnShare=false

We're seeing the consequences play out in real time. Media outlets either kiss up to power (as documented in the pieces about Trump coverage) or have lost so much public trust that corporate media is effectively dead as a credible institution--or considered as 'fake news' by 30% + of America.

Meanwhile, journalists still aren't equipped with the basic tools to call out lies in real time, to deconstruct manipulative memes, or to identify AI-generated misinformation.

The question is: How do we fix this? Your work suggests part of the answer—journalists need to be more transparent, more engaged with their communities, and more willing to explain their decision-making process.

Can national associations of journalism schools fundamentally help assessments of each school's mission. Training journalists to be stenographers for competing claims isn't enough. We need them trained as truth-seekers who understand information warfare, who can forensically analyze digital content, and who have the backbone to say "this is a lie" when something is demonstrably false.

Thanks for creating this space for these conversations. It gives me hope that there are still journalists committed to getting it right.

Expand full comment
46 more comments...

No posts